Skip to content

Foraging in the edible wild can be a life or death proposition. Beware!

The idea that anyone could live comfortably and healthy simply by eating what grows in the local woodlot is a false dream, says outdoors columnist
20080519_Yellow Morel (Hawke)
Yellow morels, shown here, are sought by many as a natural food as this species preferred by some over black morels. But do they know the difference between these lookalikes and the poisonous false morel? The edible wild can be fraught with peril. David Hawke/OrilliaMatters

You can tell that we humans are hard-wired with the need to survive, for as soon as a seasonal opportunity presents itself we revert to trying to fulfill our basic needs. I speak of course about foraging, also known as the edible wild.

In the interest of transparency, truth and just plain letting you know where I stand on the issue of gathering wild food… I’m 83.6% against it. If you are continuing to read past that last sentence, let me embellish that statement.

I’ve been blessed that my resume indicates my entire career and lifestyle has been working within the outdoors, and that I’ve tried to learn as much as I can about the natural environment that provides for both my vocation and avocation.

At one time, while leading a plant identification hike at a local resort, one of the participants blurted out that she was in awe of my knowledge and assumed that I could survive on my own if lost or living in the woods.

My reply was that yes, I’m comfortable in the woods and would gladly live there, provided of course I could get to a supermarket at least once a week!

The idea that anyone could live comfortably and healthy simply by eating what grows in the local woodlot is a false dream. Agriculture was invented to counter the starvation factor! Yet most of our foods of today do indeed have their origins as a species growing wild somewhere in the world. 

If you’ve dabbled with the edible wild, you no doubt know that there are numerous books dedicated to the topic, as well as uncountable YouTube videos and websites touting the hobby of gathering nuts and berries. However, are you also aware of the videos and books warning of poisonous plants and their negative effects on human bodies?

Of the perhaps thousands of nature walks that I’ve led, the advice of edibility rarely passes my lips. It’s not that I’m jealously misdirecting attention from a patch of yummy berries, it’s more that I’m anxious my identification and endorsement of edibility will be misunderstood.

Let’s use low-bush blueberry as an example. If I say that blueberries are good to eat and good for you, how do I know that you won’t pass along this new-found nugget of info to your friends interpreted as “Dave says blue berries are good eat?”

There is a deadly difference as to whether the descriptive word is compound or not.

Each spring sees a wave of foragers sallying forth to parks, nature reserves, local ditches and even private properties in search of fiddleheads, morels, leeks and other legendary ‘free food.’ Caution is required on both identification and preparation.

Fiddleheads are the new growth of ferns, a beautiful curving structure that quickly rises and unfurls into a full sized fern frond. Pretty easy to recognize and fairly abundant.

Apparently if prepared with a couple changes of boiling water and then pan-fried with butter they are edible. However and but, did you know that only ostrich fern is edible? All the other fern species have carcinogenic characteristics. And without that double change of boiling water even ostrich fern has attached rumours of being not the best thing you provided to your stomach today.

Mushrooms are the epitome of edible wild, with some foragers going to great lengths (including trespass) to seek out fungi to eat.

It irks me greatly whenever I point out an exquisite mushroom found growing along a trail side that the first question invariably is…“Can I eat it?”

My answer is that all mushrooms are edible, but some only once. Fungi range the entire scale from choice edible to deadly poisonous; and generally speaking they all look the same. Do you feel lucky today?

Whether something is edible or poisonous is something that leads to the discussion of toxicity. Some people can eat peanuts and enjoy the imported snack while for others it can be a rushed trip to the emergency room.

Some people can eat fish while for others it’s vying for position in the emergency room against some guy who ate peanut butter.

Toxicity is the manner in which our body processes and either accepts or rejects a certain food. Some mushroom species can indeed be eaten and digested just fine, while other mushroom species will react badly if you have a swallow of wine with that gourmet platter of fungus; depending on your personal constitution what is edible for one person may well be toxic to you. 

This condition or reaction often shows up when we eat something our body is not used to. Which is why just about every website worth looking at has the caveat that you should 100% identify and then sample lightly any new food you are trying.

The other side of picking wild food is knowing how to prepare it. Several books will simply say that the species is edible.

Lost to many of us is the knowledge of: what part of the plant is edible: the root, the leaves, the fruit? Rhubarb stems are edible (to some) but the leaves are bad news (for all). Can that basket full of harvested greenery be eaten raw, or only after boiling?

And there is that built-in problem that there are simply too many people thrashing about the underbrush looking for edibles.

Leeks were once common in the Gatineau Hills of Quebec… until they were all dug up for sale at local markets. Now leek picking (although doubtful you can even find one there) is illegal in that magnificent public forest.

Back to that assumption that I know all about edible wild… when asked if a certain mushroom is edible or not, I encourage that person to do as I do and pick their mushrooms from within the produce aisle of the supermarket.


Comments

Verified reader

If you would like to apply to become a verified commenter, please fill out this form.